What an FBI Hostage Negotiator Teaches About Winning Any Conversation

Most people reckon negotiation is about splitting the difference and finding middle ground. Chris Voss, former FBI hostage negotiator and author of “Never Split the Difference,” has a radically different approach. His FBI negotiation techniques, tested in life-or-death situations, can transform how you handle everything from business deals to family rows.

Why “Splitting the Difference” Doesn’t Work

Voss cuts straight to the heart of traditional negotiation wisdom with a simple question: How do you split the difference with a terrorist who’s got four hostages and wants a jet to Cuba plus a million dollars? Do you offer two hostages, a helicopter to New Jersey, and an Uber ride from there?

Obviously not. Some situations don’t have a logical middle ground, and many everyday negotiations fall into this category too.

The Myth of One-Off Negotiations

Here’s something most people don’t realise about hostage negotiators: they have repeat customers. Voss shares a striking example of a siege where the suspect literally coached the negotiator, saying “You’re not doing a good job. You’re supposed to be establishing rapport with me.” The criminal had been in similar situations before.

This destroys the myth that you can say anything to win because you’ll never see the person again. Reputation matters, even in extreme circumstances. If a previous negotiator had lied, lives could have been lost down the line. These FBI negotiation techniques rely on building trust, not breaking it.

Tactical Empathy: The Ultimate Weapon

Voss introduces what he calls “tactical empathy” – not the warm, fuzzy kind you might expect, but what he describes as “weapons-grade empathy.” This isn’t about liking someone or feeling sorry for them.

Tactical empathy means:

• Taking stock of the other person’s perspective
• Understanding their viewpoint, especially the bits you don’t like
• Calmly describing their position back to them
• No denials, no disagreements – just acknowledgement

Why Tactical Empathy Works on Everyone

The power of tactical empathy lies in universal human wiring. Every person has a limbic system – the emotional part of the brain that doesn’t care about your gender, ethnicity, or background. That’s why FBI negotiation techniques from Baghdad to Boston use the same core principles.

Voss explains that emotions are intertwined in all our decisions. We make choices based on what we care about, making decision-making inherently emotional. Understanding this fundamental aspect of human psychology is central to both tactical empathy and FBI negotiation techniques.

The Truth-Telling Baseline

Here’s a fascinating insight from Voss’s FBI experience: Everyone has one way they tell the truth, but five to seven different ways they might lie. This is how polygraph tests work – they establish your truth-telling baseline, then watch for deviations. These FBI negotiation techniques focus on understanding authentic communication patterns.

This principle helped identify Khalid Sheikh Mohammed as the mastermind of 9/11. By understanding someone’s authentic communication style, you can detect when something changes.

Real-World Application: The Pub Story

Voss shares a perfect example of tactical empathy in action. He and three other hostage negotiators walked into a crowded pub. When Voss approached an empty seat, the bloke next to it threatened to “kick his arse.”

Instead of escalating, Voss used tactical empathy:

• He introduced himself by name
• His colleagues surrounded the situation with curiosity, not confrontation
• They discovered the man was a Vietnam veteran whose life was falling apart
• Understanding his perspective completely changed the dynamic

The lesson? Once Voss became “Chris” instead of some nameless threat, everything shifted. People respond differently when they feel seen and understood.

From Hostages to Family Dinners

The most powerful part of Voss’s approach is its universal application. He tells the story of a successful tech executive who used tactical empathy during a difficult family gathering. His sister, stressed from caring for their dying father, had been drinking and started attacking him verbally.

Instead of defending himself, he simply listened and made her feel heard without disputing anything she said. The confrontation lasted an hour, but the next day, she sent an email saying: “Yesterday I attacked you and you showed me nothing but love. Thank you for being my big brother.”

The Key Takeaway

Voss’s central message is profound: The difficult people in your life – the “mad, bad, and sad” – are everywhere. Don’t let only terrorists and bank robbers benefit from tactical empathy.

Apply these principles to:

• Difficult colleagues and clients
• Family conflicts
• Business negotiations
• Any situation where emotions run high

The goal isn’t to manipulate or win at all costs. It’s to understand the human nature wiring we all share and use that understanding to turn adversaries into allies.

Making Tactical Empathy Practical

Start implementing tactical empathy by:

1. Listen for emotion, not just facts – What is the person really feeling?
2. Reflect back their perspective – “It sounds like you’re frustrated because…”
3. Avoid the urge to immediately counter – First understand, then respond
4. Use their name – It creates connection and humanity
5. Stay calm under pressure – Your emotional state influences theirs

These FBI negotiation techniques work because they address the emotional reality underlying every conversation. Remember: Everyone you encounter is dealing with their own version of stress, fear, or frustration. When you acknowledge that reality without judgement, you create space for real dialogue.

Voss proved tactical empathy works in the most extreme circumstances imaginable. The question is: Are you ready to try it in your everyday conversations?

Ex Nihilo is a magazine for entrepreneurs and startups, connecting them with investors and fueling the global entrepreneur movement