Popular on Ex Nihilo Magazine

Sriracha Tried to Steal Its Own Recipe

Sriracha pepper farmer

The bottle of Sriracha in your fridge does not taste the way it used to, and there is a lawsuit to explain why. Huy Fong Foods, the company behind the green-capped rooster sauce, spent much of the last three years unable to make its own product reliably, running short, hiking prices, and watching loyal customers complain the flavour had changed. This autumn a California appeals court affirmed a $23.3 million fraud judgment against the company, closing the book on how it got here. The short version is that Huy Fong tried to steal a recipe it already had access to, and destroyed it in the process.

The theft involved a drone. In the autumn of its final season with its longtime pepper farmer, Huy Fong asked Craig Underwood for permission to film his harvest. In 28 years of supplying the red jalapeños that made Sriracha famous, Underwood had never once been asked to record anything. He said yes. Huy Fong told him the footage was for personal use only.

Months later, after cutting Underwood loose, Huy Fong handed that same footage to a set of replacement farmers and used it to teach them how Underwood grew the peppers: the spacing, the timing, the irrigation, the harvesting methods four generations of one California family had spent decades refining. The drone was never about personal use. It was an attempt to copy the one part of the Sriracha business Huy Fong did not own and could not buy, and to make the farmer who held it disposable. The attempt failed completely, and the way it failed is what makes the story worth telling.

The Handshake That Built a Brand

David Tran started Huy Fong Foods in 1980, naming it after the freighter that carried him out of Vietnam. In 1988 a California farmer named Craig Underwood wrote to him offering to grow jalapeños, and a partnership began that would run for nearly three decades almost entirely on a handshake.

The arrangement was simple and, for most of its life, worked beautifully. Tran prepaid each season’s crop. Underwood planted. “You grow it, I’ll sell it,” Tran told him, and Underwood did, expanding his operation year after year to keep pace with Sriracha’s climb from a niche sauce in pho restaurants to a global icon. By 2006, Underwood Ranches was growing 95% of every pepper Huy Fong used.

Why the Handshake Mattered

The two men were close enough that Underwood attended the weddings of Tran’s children. That closeness is not sentimental colour. It is the legal and commercial heart of what happened next.

A relationship that runs for 28 years on trust rather than paper builds something that does not sit on any balance sheet: a set of mutual obligations everyone understands and nobody has written down. It works for decades precisely because both sides honour it without being forced to. That also makes it easy to exploit the moment one side decides to stop honouring it, which is exactly what Huy Fong would eventually try.

The Trap Underwood Walked Into

By 2016, Huy Fong accounted for roughly 80% of Underwood Ranches’ revenue. On Huy Fong’s repeated insistence that it would buy every pepper the farm could grow, Underwood had taken on more land and more equipment, planting 1,700 acres for the 2017 season at Huy Fong’s urging.

This is the concentration risk every business textbook warns about, one customer representing most of your income, and Underwood had walked straight into it. When the relationship ended, the damage was immediate and brutal. Underwood had to lay off nearly half his workforce in the first year. On paper, he was the vulnerable party, the small farm that had bent its entire existence around a single buyer.

The Dependency Ran Both Ways

Huy Fong never seemed to register that the dependency ran both ways. It had built its entire product around one farm’s peppers just as completely as that farm had built itself around Huy Fong’s orders.

The difference was in how each side read the situation. Huy Fong believed the peppers were a commodity it could re-source from any competent farm. Underwood’s operation, in Huy Fong’s eyes, was a replaceable supplier that happened to be large. That belief is the single most expensive assumption in the entire story, and it was wrong.

The Exit Tran Was Already Building

Tran had been planning his departure since at least 2014, when he formed a company called Chilico, designed to take over pepper sourcing and cut Underwood out. He also tried to hire away Jim Roberts, Underwood’s chief operations officer and the key figure in its pepper production, the man who had co-developed the farm’s mechanical harvester.

The drone fit the same pattern. In October 2016, while Huy Fong was still pushing Underwood to plant for a 2017 season it had already privately decided to cancel, it asked to film the harvest. Roberts granted permission for Huy Fong’s personal use only. Huy Fong had never asked before. Months later, Tran showed that confidential footage to the new farmers he had lined up, explaining how to replicate the harvesting techniques Underwood had spent four generations perfecting.

The Lawsuit

Huy Fong planted its trap in the open. Underwood planted the 2017 crop as instructed, and Huy Fong refused to buy it. In August 2017, Huy Fong sued Underwood first, demanding the return of a $1.46 million overpayment from the 2016 season. Underwood countersued for fraud and breach of contract.

The jury did not find this a close call. In 2019 it ruled for Underwood, awarding $23.3 million, later affirmed on appeal: $13.32 million in compensation and $10 million in punitive damages, with the $1.46 million overpayment deducted.

What the Court Saw

The legal reasoning is the part worth a business reader’s attention. Huy Fong argued it had no obligation to warn Underwood it was leaving. The court disagreed, and the grounds it gave were specific: after 28 years of near-exclusive dealing, a “confidential relationship” had formed between the two companies, and that relationship carried a legal duty to disclose.

Because Underwood had built his entire operation on Huy Fong’s promise that it would keep buying, Huy Fong was obligated to tell him when that stopped being true. Justice Arthur Gilbert, writing for the appeals court, pointed to the evidence that Tran had planned to cut ties well before he did, had shared the confidential drone footage with competitors, and had tried to poach Underwood’s key executive. The handshake Huy Fong thought carried no obligations turned out to carry the heaviest ones in the case.

The Theft That Didn’t Work

Here is where the greed turns on itself. The entire point of the drone footage was to make Underwood replaceable, to capture his methods so that any farmer could grow the Sriracha pepper. Huy Fong got the footage, showed it to its new growers, and the new growers still could not do what Underwood did.

The footage captured what Underwood did. It could not capture how four generations of accumulated judgment knew when to do it: which day to harvest, how to read a season, the thousand small calls that never get written down because the people making them stopped having to think about them a generation ago. That knowledge was the product. The drone only ever saw its output.

What Happened to Sriracha

In 2022, Huy Fong halted Sriracha production entirely, citing a shortage of peppers of sufficient quality. The halt lasted more than a year. Bottles that normally sold for a few dollars were changing hands for $30 and up on the secondary market. Longtime customers complained the sauce, when it returned, no longer tasted the way it used to. By the most recent accounts, Huy Fong has still not secured a consistent supply of peppers at the quality it once took for granted.

Meanwhile the farmer Huy Fong fired started making his own Sriracha, from the same peppers, on the same land, with the same knowledge. Underwood sells it at farmers’ markets and beyond, and his verdict on his former partner’s product is the sharpest line in the whole saga. “Without Underwood’s pepper,” he said, “it’s just another condiment.”

The Paperwork Wasn’t the Problem

The lesson here is not simply “get it in writing,” though a proper contract would have protected Underwood, since the vagueness of the handshake is precisely what Huy Fong exploited to try to walk away without consequence. Paper would have helped the farmer.

But paper would not have fixed Huy Fong’s actual mistake, because the deeper error was never about documentation. It was about which part of the business was the commodity and which was the moat.

The Commodity That Was the Moat

Huy Fong assumed the brand was irreplaceable and the pepper was interchangeable, a raw input it could source from any competent farm once it had the specs. It had this exactly backwards. The brand was replaceable enough that a year-long shortage and a quality collapse genuinely damaged it, while the pepper, or rather the decades of tacit knowledge in how to grow that specific pepper at scale, was the one asset that could not be copied, bought, or filmed.

Companies make this mistake constantly, usually without a drone to make it obvious. They squeeze the supplier, the contractor, the long-tenured employee whose value is hard to quantify precisely because it was never written down, on the assumption that the relationship is a cost rather than the product. Huy Fong is simply the clearest case on record of a company that destroyed the thing it was selling in order to stop paying for it, and then watched a 36-year-old brand become, in its former partner’s words, just another condiment.

Sources

FindLaw (California Court of Appeal ruling)

Bloomberg Law

NBC News

Fortune

Modern Farmer


Ex Nihilo magazine is for entrepreneurs and startups, connecting them with investors and fueling the global entrepreneur movement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *