Toyota Nearly Lost Everything in 2010. This Is How They Came Back

How the 2009-2010 Recall Disaster Forced the World’s Largest Automaker to Embrace Humility

Mark Saylor was a California Highway Patrol officer. On 28 August 2009, he was off duty, driving his family in a borrowed Lexus ES350 near San Diego. Then the car started speeding up on its own.

The accelerator was stuck. The brakes weren’t working. In those final moments, a passenger called 911: “We’re in a Lexus… and our accelerator is stuck… there’s no brakes… Hold on and pray… pray.”

All four people died when the car crashed.

This single tragedy would spark the Toyota recall crisis, forcing the company to recall nearly 8 million vehicles and changing how the world saw Japan’s most famous carmaker.

When Being Number One Backfired

For years, everyone wanted to copy Toyota. Business schools taught their production methods. Other car companies studied their quality control. They seemed to do everything right.

But by 2009, cracks were showing. Toyota had been racing to become the world’s biggest carmaker, and they’d won. The problem? They’d grown too fast.

“We pursued growth over the speed at which we were able to develop our people and our organisation,” Akio Toyoda later told Congress. Put simply, Toyota had more factories and cars than they could properly manage.

The actual problems were surprisingly basic. Some floor mats could slide forward and trap the accelerator pedal. Some pedals, made by a supplier, were sticky and slow to spring back. These weren’t computer glitches or design disasters. They were simple mechanical issues that should have been spotted.

Between November 2009 and January 2010, Toyota recalled 3.8 million vehicles for the floor mat problem, then another 2.3 million for sticky pedals. Customers were panicking. The media smelled blood.

Lost in Translation

Here’s where culture crashed into crisis. In Japan, admitting failure publicly brings deep shame. Companies typically stay quiet, fix problems behind the scenes, then move on. But Americans wanted answers immediately. They wanted someone to blame. They wanted apologies.

Toyota’s initial response to the recall crisis was a disaster. For weeks, they said almost nothing. When they did speak, they blamed drivers for using the wrong floor mats. They insisted their first recalls would fix everything.

Ray LaHood, America’s Transportation Secretary, was furious. He accused Toyota of being “safety deaf” and had to personally ring Akio Toyoda to demand action.

The Toyota recall crisis hit rock bottom in late January 2010. Toyota did something unthinkable: they stopped selling and making eight of their most popular models. For a company obsessed with efficiency and continuous production, this was like admitting defeat.

Facing the Music

On 24 February 2010, Akio Toyoda sat in front of angry American politicians in Washington. The 53-year-old grandson of Toyota’s founder had tried to send someone else in his place, but Congress insisted he come personally.

“My name is on every car,” he said in heavily accented English. “You have my personal commitment that Toyota will work vigorously and unceasingly to restore the trust of our customers.”

For three hours, politicians from both parties tore into him. “Where is the remorse?” demanded Marcy Kaptur. John Mica waved an internal Toyota document that boasted about saving $100 million by limiting an earlier recall. “Absolutely appalling!” he shouted.

But something changed that evening. Speaking to Toyota dealers afterwards, Toyoda broke down crying. “You were there with me,” he said through tears. This wasn’t acting. In Japan, when a CEO cries publicly, it means something profound. He was genuinely devastated.

The Truth Comes Out

As investigators dug deeper, the story got more complicated. NASA engineers found no problems with Toyota’s electronics. Government data showed that while Toyota had complaints, other carmakers like Volkswagen and Suzuki actually had higher rates of acceleration problems.

The damage was still massive. Toyota paid over $2 billion in immediate costs, plus $48.8 million in fines. Their stock dropped 30%. Ford’s stock, meanwhile, went up 80% as customers fled to competitors.

Yet something odd happened. By March 2010, just weeks after the Congressional grilling, Toyota’s sales bounced back. A survey found Toyota owners still trusted the company. They’d still buy another Toyota.

Why? Because Toyota had spent decades building trust. One crisis, however awful, couldn’t erase all those years of reliable cars.

Back to Basics

Toyota could have made excuses. They could have blamed suppliers or the media or panicky customers. Instead, they looked in the mirror.

Toyota created new quality control positions and introduced systems to ensure customer complaints reached top management faster. It also installed brake override technology so the brakes would always take priority over the accelerator. Most importantly, they embraced what they call “hansei” – deep self-reflection about what went wrong.

“We have to rethink everything about our operations,” Toyoda said. The company that taught the world about continuous improvement was finally improving itself.

This wasn’t just corporate talk. Toyota went back to their roots: listening to workers on the factory floor, focusing on quality over quantity, and fixing problems at their source. They stopped chasing growth and started chasing excellence again.

Stronger Through Failure

By 2011, Toyota had not only recovered from the recall crisis but come back stronger. They were the world’s biggest carmaker again. They were winning quality awards. The Toyota recall crisis that nearly destroyed them had actually saved them.

The company discovered they’d lost their way while trying to conquer the world. The crisis forced them back to what made them great: obsessing over quality, respecting workers’ insights, and never thinking they were too big to fail.

The Toyota recall crisis taught them that being human – making mistakes, admitting them, and learning from them – was more important than being perfect. Companies that pretend they never fail eventually fail spectacularly. Companies that embrace their failures can turn them into strengths.

As one analyst put it: “Toyota’s crisis proved that decades of doing things right matters more than months of doing things wrong.”

Today, when Toyota executives discuss the Toyota recall crisis, they don’t try to hide it. They call it a gift – a horrible, expensive gift that reminded them who they really were. Not the biggest carmaker. Not the most profitable. Just a company trying to make good cars and keep improving, one small step at a time.

The crisis didn’t make Toyota perfect. But it made them honest about being imperfect. And sometimes, that’s exactly what customers need to see.

Sources

1. U.S. Department of Transportation. (2010). “U.S. Department Of Transportation Releases Results From NHTSA-NASA Study Of Unintended Acceleration In Toyota Vehicles.”
2. Congressional Testimony. (2010). “Akio Toyoda Congressional Testimony Before House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform.” February 24, 2010. CBS News coverage:
3. Motor Trend. (2010). “The Toyota Recall Crisis – A chronology of the Toyota pedal, floormat recall.” January 27, 2010.
4. PBS NewsHour. (2010). “Toyota Chief’s Emotional Apology Resonates in Japan.” Interview with Ayako Doi. February 25, 2010.
5. Department of Justice. (2014). “Statement of Facts: Toyota Motor Corporation Deferred Prosecution Agreement.”
6. ABC News. (2010). “Toyota CEO Akio Toyoda’s Apology: ‘I Take Full Responsibility’.” February 24, 2010.

Ex Nihilo magazine is for entrepreneurs and startups, connecting them with investors and fueling the global entrepreneur movement